Tips and Advice vs Giving Away the Farm: Is there such a thing?
I admit -- this is a concept I struggle with. Like I’ve said in previous posts, as your recruiter I want you to be set up for success, and I want to help provide the toolbox to get you there. But at the same time, I also want you to do well on your own horsepower as much as possible.
It’s a frustrating conundrum. I want you to succeed, but I want you to interview as you -- perhaps the best representation of you, but still you. Paraphrasing Chris Rock’s joke on dating describes it almost perfectly: When you’re on a first date, you’re not you. You’re the ambassador of you.
This is kind of how it is during a job interview. You’re not quite yourself -- you’re portraying the best version of yourself. Interview tips and advice can serve to improve awareness and help you become a better ambassador -- but it’s a fine line. And at what point does the person following advice no longer become the best version of themselves, but the version of themselves I want to see?
Deep, huh?
This is a conversation I’ve had with many peers and hiring managers. It’s always a fun and interesting exercise to go through. In the end, I think there are two values held in high esteem at Microsoft that help to balance this out: honesty and integrity. In my opinion, this is part of why we have each candidate interview with a minimum of three or four Microsofties. Most recruiters (and trained interviewers) are pretty good at catching inconsistencies. And though most candidates are capable of searching the net for all sorts of advice, it’s tough to fake it if you don’t mean it. Probability dictates that inconsistencies will surface when examined at the macro level.
So what do you think? Is there a difference between advising a candidate and leading a candidate? Sound back. I’d like to hear your thoughts!!
In the meantime, stay tuned for my next post where I’ll be putting together a list of my favorite interview advice.
-Kenji


4 Comments
Ask a Manager said:
I wonder this all the time too, especially because I have a blog that could be used as a cheat sheet to how to interview well with me. Yet somehow, people aren't able to fake it that well. The best candidates still stand out, and the ones that aren't ... don't. I think it might be that the most competent people are the most able to benefit from advice, although that sounds rather snotty.
Freelancer München said:
I am already looking forward for your next post
BlogMS Weekly Articles Published – 4th May to 10th May said:
242 Microsoft Team blogs searched, 118 blogs have new articles in the past 7 days. 314 new articles found
david said:
Good post Kenji, you have to sell yourself - but no lying. It's a difficult skill to pick up.